Skip to content

Publication

Myths about weapons. Myth #3 “Only security forces should have weapons”

This myth is very often repeated with encouragement by people who are simply not ready to take responsibility for their safety and will gladly shift it to someone else. They are used to someone making too many decisions for them, including political, economic, security, etc.

Realizing their personal total legal illiteracy, ignorance of their rights and obligations, they understand that in a critical situation they will not be able to make a balanced decision on actions to protect themselves or their families.

Therefore, instead of choosing a responsible person – choosing personal growth, which requires some effort and time, they choose what only requires a compromise with their own conscience and the safety of their relatives – avoiding responsibility and demanding someone else to defend their safety.

However, some of these people try to rationalize their timid choice, saying: “Doctors should treat, teachers should teach, security forces should defend. Everyone should do their job”. And it seems to be so: the division of labor gave impetus to the development of mankind, however, it is only a barren sophistry that has not much in common with reality.

It is easy to see this just by remembering that in certain situations, it is not doctors who provide effective first aid that saves lives; in addition to teachers, children are also raised by their parents personally; there are many examples when ordinary citizens come to the rescue first, and the police arrive only after a certain time.

So what is the essence of the myth? What is the mistake, what is wrong with it?

A distinctive feature of free citizens is the belief that they are responsible for their own destiny, and any state institution is only a tool for solving a certain range of issues. And what is very important to understand – where this tool stalls and does not help, the issue must be resolved in another way! There is no other way.

Failure to understand this simple fact is a mistake that can be very costly. When you become the object of an attack or other illegal encroachment, in almost 100% of cases there is a certain period of time when you are alone with the threat. And at this time only you are responsible for your life and health. Yes, maybe later there will be police, special forces, helicopters and everything else – but we must live to see this moment. And your weapons can help you. Not the weapon of the police officer in the car coming towards you, but your personal weapon.

Equally important is the aspect that people who repeat this myth mistakenly exaggerate the limits of powers and capabilities of representatives of law enforcement agencies. They have an unfounded and false prejudice that “people in uniform” are somehow fundamentally different from people without uniform – from you. Absolutely ignored is the fact that “people in uniform” are the same Ukrainians – neither worse nor better. Among them there are both professionals and completely unfit; there are those who are conscientious about their duties, and those who avoid their duties.

And even if you were just fabulously lucky and a police patrol was right next to you during the attack – it does not mean that they will be able to help you at all for the reasons stated in the sentence above.

Does the uniform worn by someone still make a magical impression on you?

Well, then let’s just answer the following question: is it at least logical that in order to give up the right to armed protection and deliberately hand over all weapons to the security forces, a person must trust them at least that much? But it is probably logical.

And what is the actual state of affairs with trust in the security forces in Ukrainian society?

This question will be answered by a number of studies conducted by the Razumkov Centre sociological service in 2016, 2017 and 2018. Research topic: “Trust of Ukrainian citizens in public institutions”.

Respondents were asked a simple question such as “to what extent do you trust the following social institutions?”. The list of state law enforcement agencies included, in particular, the National Police and the Patrol Police. And the answer options: “do not trust at all”, “rather do not trust”, “rather trust”, “completely trust”.

So, interesting for our history will be the fact that these law enforcement agencies, which are responsible for the protection of human rights and freedoms, combating crime, maintaining public safety and order, are much more distrusted than trusted. The research materials are publicly available.

That’s all. Taking into account the awareness of this fact, there is no reason to say that “only the security forces should have weapons”.

So, this myth is destroyed.

Movement of gun owners “Your voice will make a difference”